Subaru Forester excessive oil consumption and engine knocking while idling on Subaru Forester

Submitted by Vehicle Owner · Jun 23, 2025
Published by RepairPal

Problem overview

Some Subaru Forester owners report experiencing excessive oil consumption, particularly in older models with the 2.5-liter naturally aspirated four-cylinder engine. This issue can lead to significant engine problems, including the need for major repairs or even engine replacement. Contributing factors to this excessive consumption include worn seals or gaskets causing leaks, poor oil quality, worn piston rings, and high oil pressure flooding the engine. Additionally, some owners report hearing engine knocking while idling, which may indicate low oil levels or other serious issues, potentially leading to rough idling, increased fuel consumption, and engine stalling. It is crucial for owners experiencing these symptoms to seek inspection from a qualified technician, especially if they notice unusual sounds or potential leaks. Subaru has implemented measures to address these concerns, including settlements for free oil-consumption testing and extended warranties for affected models. Prompt attention to these issues is essential to prevent further engine damage and ensure the longevity of the Subaru Forester.

1 person reported this problem
0 comments
Schedule Repair

Subaru Forester vehicles with this problem

0 model year affected

Search for another problem

RepairPal Car Genius

Ask our experts about your Subaru.

RepairPal Car Genius™ is a free resource for vehicle owners seeking advice on maintenance, auto repair, shop inquiries, estimates, and finding a trustworthy repair shop in your area.

 Auto Repair Expert Auto Repair Expert

Call us at 877-913-1554

Available 9am – 6pm ET Monday through Friday

Call Our Experts